15 Best Boutique Hotels in the Midwest in 2023
Condé Nast Traveler readers rated the top hotels in the country’s heartland, and if you’re a fan of boutique hotels with unique amenities, you won’t want to miss the 2023 Reader’s Choice Awards winners for best hotels in the Midwest.
1. JW Marriott Indianapolis
Indianapolis, Indiana
This luxurious hotel is located in the heart of downtown Indianapolis and offers stunning views of the city skyline. With more than 1,000 guest rooms, a full-service spa, and multiple dining options, the JW Marriott is the perfect choice for travelers seeking a high-end experience in the Midwest.
The building is stunning both inside and out, offering breathtaking views of the city. Moreover, its ideal location puts it within easy walking distance of numerous major attractions, restaurants, and vibrant nightlife activities.
The rooms are designed for utmost comfort, with an adjustable thermostat that allows guests to maintain an ideal sleeping temperature. The friendly and helpful staff contribute to a pleasant stay. Moreover, the higher floors offer amazing views, while the nearby river and canal paths are easily accessible for leisurely strolls.
As an added bonus, two museums are conveniently located across the street, with the Eiteljorg Museum featuring a charming café for a delightful lunch experience.
2. The Pfister Hotel
Milwaukee, Wisconsin
This historic hotel in Milwaukee, Wisconsin has been a beloved landmark since 1893. With its ornate architecture, elegant guest rooms, and world-class dining, the Pfister is a must-visit destination for anyone seeking a taste of old-world charm in the Midwest.
This exceptional hotel offers an outstanding experience. It boasts an elegant atmosphere at a surprisingly reasonable price point. The rooms are beautifully designed and provide both comfort and aesthetic appeal. The service is impeccable, with a thoughtful touch of complimentary champagne during check-in.
The hotel offers a wide range of amenities, including a stunning 23rd-floor bar with panoramic city views, a luxurious pool, a well-equipped gym, and relaxing spa facilities. With its comprehensive offerings and affordable rates, this hotel truly caters to every need and preference.
3. Detroit Foundation Hotel
Detroit, Michigan
This boutique hotel in downtown Detroit is housed in a beautifully restored 1929 fire station. With 100 guest rooms, a rooftop lounge, and a restaurant serving locally sourced cuisine, the Detroit Foundation Hotel is a unique and stylish choice for travelers.
This hotel offers an incredible experience from start to finish. The impeccable service begins with a warm welcome when you arrive and extends throughout your stay, including interactions during check-in and dining at The Apparatus Room. The overall quality of the food, drinks, service, and accommodations is exceptional.
The hotel exudes beauty and thoughtful design at every turn, complemented by a genuinely hospitable staff. The staff excels in providing recommendations for exploring the local area, enhancing your visit.
4. Saint Kate – The Arts Hotel
Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Located in Milwaukee’s trendy Third Ward neighborhood, Saint Kate is a boutique hotel that celebrates the arts in all its forms. With more than 200 pieces of art on display throughout the hotel, as well as a theater and multiple galleries, Saint Kate is the perfect choice for art lovers visiting the Midwest.
This boutique hotel exudes a distinct sense of uniqueness and charm. Its elegant lobby, cocktail bar, and restaurant create a visually captivating atmosphere. The rooms are thoughtfully designed, blending modern conveniences with a tasteful vintage aesthetic. The attentive and genuinely friendly staff further enhance the overall experience.
The hotel’s location is another noteworthy attribute, positioned in a prime area that allows for convenient walking access to numerous theaters, as well as an array of exceptional restaurants and cocktail bars.
5. Ironworks Hotel
Indianapolis, Indiana
This industrial-chic hotel in Indianapolis is housed in a former ironworks factory, giving it a unique and stylish vibe. With 120 guest rooms, a restaurant serving farm-to-table cuisine, and a rooftop bar, the Ironworks Hotel is a hip and trendy choice for travelers seeking something different in the Midwest.
“We couldn’t be more proud to have earned the Conde Nast Traveler’s Readers Choice Award and rank as one of the top hotels in the Midwest. Our incredible staff works each day with the guest experience as their highest priority. This award is a testament to our team’s commitment to quality and care.”
– Anthony Richardson, general manager of Ironworks Hotel Indy
This boutique hotel on the north side of town stands out for its modern and sophisticated decor, offering a distinctive atmosphere. The level of service provided is exemplary, and the rooms are tastefully appointed, ensuring a comfortable and enjoyable stay. Its location is strategically convenient for events in the northern region and Carmel, with the added benefit of being just a short 15-minute drive from downtown.
Additionally, it is adjacent to the upscale shopping at The Fashion Mall at Keystone, offering a plethora of retail options. Guests will also find a variety of dining choices within the hotel, including the delightful brunch spot, Rize.
6. Shinola Hotel
Detroit, Michigan
This boutique hotel in downtown Detroit is named after the iconic American brand known for its watches and leather goods. With 129 guest rooms, a fine-dining restaurant, and stunning views of the city from its rooftop bar, the Shinola Hotel is a must-visit destination for design-minded travelers.
The hotel exudes a captivating charm, featuring intricate and thoughtfully designed architectural and artistic elements throughout its premises. The striking red facade of the hotel and the neighboring Detroit skyscrapers boast hand-carved details reminiscent of European cathedrals, adding a touch of grandeur to the cityscape.
The interior of the hotel seamlessly upholds the high standards set by its exterior architecture. The lobby, in particular, welcomes guests with warmth and sophistication. It showcases a diverse collection of local and iconic artwork, alongside modern lounge chairs, ottomans, and couches that invite relaxation and conversation.
The marble staircase in the lobby is another noteworthy highlight, gleaming with elegance. Be sure to take notice of the ornate golden handrail, which adds a touch of opulence to the overall ambiance.
7. Hewing Hotel
Minneapolis, Minnesota
This boutique hotel in Minneapolis is housed in a beautifully restored brick-and-timber warehouse in the North Loop neighborhood. With 124 guest rooms and a restaurant serving Nordic-inspired cuisine, the Hewing Hotel is a stylish and unique choice for travelers visiting the Midwest.
This high-quality hotel meticulously attends to every detail, ensuring a well-rounded and enjoyable experience. The ambiance it offers is a delightful blend of rustic and modern aesthetics, creating a unique and inviting atmosphere. Guests may notice a subtle smoky scent that harmonizes perfectly with the dark tones, ambient lighting, and woodland-inspired decor, enhancing the overall ambiance.
Located in a vibrant neighborhood, the hotel is surrounded by numerous dining options and a lively nightlife scene, providing ample opportunities for entertainment and exploration. The room itself meets high standards, offering excellent accommodations, and the amenities provided are thoughtfully designed and well-executed, ensuring a comfortable and memorable stay.
8. The Hotel at Oberlin
Oberlin, Ohio
This eco-friendly hotel in Oberlin, Ohio is the perfect choice for travelers seeking sustainability and modern design. With 70 guest rooms, a farm-to-table restaurant, and a LEED Platinum certification, the Hotel at Oberlin is a great choice for eco-conscious travelers.
Nestled in an ideal location, this hotel boasts both beauty and convenience. Immaculate cleanliness characterizes the establishment, with a consistently pleasant fragrance wafting through the air. The restaurant’s staff members are exceptional in their service.
Guests will appreciate the exceptional quality of the beds and linens, offering some of the most comfortable night’s sleep imaginable. The Hotel at Oberlin is a highly recommended choice for discerning travelers.
9. The Vault Hotel
Houghton, Michigan
This boutique hotel in Houghton, Michigan is housed in a beautifully restored bank building, complete with original vaults and safety deposit boxes. The Vault Hotel is a unique and stylish choice for travelers seeking something different in the Midwest.
The Vault is a delightful 33-room boutique hotel set within a historic bank building. It showcases impeccable decor that adds to its charm. The hotel offers guests comfortable beds, complete with blackout shades to ensure a restful night’s sleep.
One of the highlights of the stay is the breakfast, which includes delicious mini-quiches catering to both vegetarians (broccoli) and non-vegetarians (ham). The spread also features bagels and coffee, and a fully stocked refrigerator filled with cold water and La Croix, providing an unexpected and delightful surprise for guests.
For a truly unique experience, guests are encouraged to visit the Counting Room located downstairs, where they can savor incredible cocktails. The Vault’s location in Houghton is strategically situated for exploring the Keweenaw Peninsula, making it an ideal base for those looking to explore the area’s natural beauty and attractions.
10. Island House Hotel
Mackinac Island, Michigan
Nestled on Mackinac Island’s Main Street, this hotel offers a prime location, directly facing the picturesque Lake Huron shoreline and just a few blocks away from the bustling downtown area. Its proximity to the waterfront and downtown makes it incredibly convenient for leisurely strolls and boutique shopping.
For those seeking outdoor activities, the hotel provides bicycle rentals, allowing guests to explore the 8.2-mile perimeter of the island. This cycling route offers a pleasant and relatively flat terrain, with scenic views along the entire journey.
The culinary offerings at the Island House restaurant, 1852 Grill, are a highlight of the stay. Guests can savor delightful breakfasts featuring real eggs and enjoy two dinners marked by perfectly prepared dishes and impeccable service. The dining experience is elevated with live music performed by a talented pianist, adding a touch of elegance.
The hotel also offers a range of amenities, including a pool and hot tub, a second casual outdoor restaurant known as The Ice House, and a designated area for lawn games on the back lawn of the property.
While the rooms may not exude luxuriousness, they provide a comfortable and cozy ambiance. It’s important to note that this is a historic hotel, and the room design is thoughtfully in keeping with the building’s architectural style and heritage.
Related: This Upper Peninsula Hotel is One of the 10 Best Historic Hotels in the US
11. Bottleworks Hotel
Indianapolis, Indiana
This boutique hotel in Indianapolis is housed in a former Coca-Cola bottling plant, giving it a unique and industrial-chic vibe. The Bottleworks Hotel is a hip and trendy choice for travelers visiting the Midwest.
Exquisite attention to detail defines every aspect of this hotel, creating an atmosphere of luxury and comfort that extends throughout the entire property. The 139 spacious guest rooms are thoughtfully designed, offering a blend of coziness and elegant touches that enhance the overall experience.
Guests will find the staff to be exceptionally friendly and accommodating, consistently delivering helpful assistance. The housekeeping team demonstrates a commitment to excellence, ensuring meticulous cleanliness and care during the daily room turnovers.
12. Hotel Iroquois
Mackinac Island, Michigan
This historic hotel on Mackinac Island, Michigan has been a beloved landmark since 1904. With 46 guest rooms, multiple dining options, and stunning views of the Straits of Mackinac, the Hotel Iroquois is a must-visit destination for travelers seeking old-world charm in the Midwest.
This property stands as a testament to its beauty, cleanliness, and efficient management. Its strategic location at the end of the main street strikes a balance between tranquility and accessibility, providing an ideal setting for a relaxed stroll.
The hotel staff members leave a lasting impression with their impressive, friendly, and helpful service. Guests can find serenity in the round, four-season room situated at the front of the hotel, offering a peaceful vantage point to observe and listen to the gentle activity passing by.
A culinary highlight awaits at the Carriage House restaurant, where guests can indulge in one of the most memorable dining experiences in their travels. Dining al fresco on the patio elevates the meal into an exceptional and unforgettable experience.
13. 21c Museum Hotel Oklahoma City
Oklahoma City, Oklahoma
Note: This hotel has recently switched ownership and management and is now the Fordson Hotel.
Nestled in the heart of the West Village District, just moments away from downtown Oklahoma City, lies the Fordson Hotel. This historic hotel is situated within the former Ford Motor Company Assembly Plant, which boasts over a century of rich history and is listed on the National Register of Historic Places.
Drawing inspiration from the enterprising spirit of Fred Jones – a local industrialist, civic leader, and one of the largest Ford dealers in the country during the 1950s – the Fordson Hotel stands as the only historical landmark in Oklahoma City associated with blue-collar industry. The hotel proudly embraces the rich history of the Ford Motor Company, utilizing authentic design and contemporary furnishings to accentuate its industrial heritage.
Guests can unwind in the relaxed lobby, inviting public spaces, and 135 guest rooms and suites, which offer a comfortable retreat with high ceilings. The property also features 14,000 square feet of meeting and event spaces, including a grand ballroom, spa, and fitness center.
Mary Eddy’s Dining Room pays homage to the golden era of American cuisine, offering a refined twist on classic dishes. Meanwhile, Pool Bar serves up casual, social dining with a playful menu and refreshing cocktails. For those in need of a quick bite or beverage at any time of day, Bodega is the go-to spot.
With large steel windows and custom-designed furniture, the Fordson Hotel perfectly blends the past and present to create a truly unique experience.
14. Delafield Hotel
Delafield, Wisconsin
This beautiful hotel boasts a colonial-inspired design that seamlessly blends with the charming ambiance of downtown Delafield. Despite its classic theme, the hotel is equipped with a range of modern amenities for the comfort of its guests.
The room pleasantly surprises with its generous size, featuring a spacious sitting area complete with a large television, complemented by another sizable flat-screen TV in the sleeping area. This layout provides ample space for various activities. The bathroom is a standout feature, offering a top-notch experience with a refreshing rainfall shower that delivers an abundant flow of water.
Convenience is a hallmark of the hotel’s location, as it is situated within a short walking distance of all the downtown attractions. Additionally, guests have the added benefit of access to a three-story gym next door, which offers instructor-led fitness classes. Overall, this stay offers an excellent experience.
15. 21c Museum Hotel Cincinnati
Cincinnati, Ohio
Situated in the heart of downtown Cincinnati, this establishment is a true hidden gem. The experience at 21c Museum Hotel earns a solid five-star rating in every aspect. From the moment you arrive, the valet staff welcomes you with warmth, courtesy, and valuable assistance.
Upon check-in, the staff’s hospitality is exceptional, creating an instant sense of belonging and providing valuable insights about both the hotel and its surroundings. The guest rooms are a delightful blend of beauty and uniqueness, featuring a design and amenities that are truly top-notch. Staying here may even inspire ideas for your own home.
For those seeking a memorable date night, the hotel offers a complete experience without the need to venture far. The museum within the premises provides a thought-provoking and enjoyable exhibit to explore. Later, dining at Metropole, conveniently connected to the hotel, offers a delicious culinary experience complemented by friendly staff.
Guests have access to a well-maintained and 24-hour gym on-site, ensuring that fitness needs are met at any time. Overall, the stay at 21c Cincinnati leaves guests thoroughly delighted, and many look forward to returning in the near future. Gratitude is extended to all the dedicated team members at 21c Cincinnati for making the experience exceptional.
Experience the Best Hotels in the Midwest
Overall, these 15 hotels stand out for their exceptional quality, unique features, and unbeatable locations in the Midwest. From historic landmarks to industrial-chic boutiques, these hotels offer something for every type of traveler, making them the best of the best in the Midwest.
This article was first published by Rooted Wanderings.
