Best Hybrid King Mattress Under $500 | According to a Busy Mom of Five

Busy parents don’t have time to sit and wade through hundreds of options when shopping for the best hybrid king mattress under $500. I’ve done the leg work so you don’t have to. Keep reading to see why these king mattresses made my short list.

---

Our pillow-top innerspring mattress is 9+ years old, and it is sagging badly. It’s no wonder we wake up sore and struggle to stand up straight some days!

Finally deciding that we couldn’t put it off any longer, I started researching king mattresses. And oh my word, the mattress ads started popping up everywhere!

Each one claimed to be “the best” with “unique” materials or manufacturing techniques that made it the “perfect” mattress for me.

I definitely got overwhelmed quickly.

Questions to Consider When Mattress Shopping

With so many options available, I needed to know what type of mattress I wanted…

• Do I want an innerspring, pillow top, hybrid, gel memory foam. Bamboo memory foam, or something else all together? (And what is the difference between them all?)
• Is it better to buy a standard king mattress or should I consider buying two twin XL mattresses and putting my pillow topper across them to make a king size mattress?
• Should I order from Amazon (and use my two-day Prime free shipping) or order directly from the manufacturer’s website (and possibly get better customer service in case of issues)?
• Is it worth it to pay a few hundred dollars more for a mattress with fewer negative reviews or should I risk a handful of negative reviews and save money?
• Do I need a soft, medium, or firm mattress?
• Should I base the firmness of the mattress on my tendency to sleep on my side or my husband’s tendency to sleep on his back?
• Should I take into consideration the fact that I work from my bed – does it need extra firmness for comfort when sitting on it?

Those are just a few of the questions I kept debating as I did my research (and basically ignored the rest of my life for few days).

Deciding on a Hybrid King Mattress Under $500

I read lots and lots of reviews and researching the different options and decided we were going to try a hybrid king mattress. I set my budget at $500 (including shipping) and narrowed the list.

Most of the lower priced memory foam mattresses seemed to give out after a couple years. My hope is that a combination of spring and foam will have the best lifespan/cost ratio.

Best Hybrid King Mattress Under $500

Here are the mattresses I considered for the best hybrid king mattress under $500.

(All of the mattresses I considered are available for purchase on Amazon and either qualify for Prime shipping or free shipping. At the time of posting, all mattresses were priced at $500 or less.)

LUCID 12 Inch King Hybrid Mattress – Bamboo Charcoal and Aloe Vera Infused Memory Foam – Motion Isolating Springs – CertiPUR-US Certified

This mattress is available as a 10″ or 12″ mattress, and it has an optional adjustable base set.

The top layers include 3.5″ of memory foam. The memory foam is infused with bamboo charcoal, eliminating odors, and cradling your body while you sleep. High-quality transition foam infused with aloe vera creates a calming and relaxing sleep environment that promotes daily freshness.

Enduring and conformable medium-plush support is provided by individually-wrapped, high-quality steel coils. Created to provide luxury at an affordable price, this mattress is backed by a 10-year U.S. warranty against manufacturer defects.

The 12″ mattress (which is what I was considering) is a medium-plush firmness with a deeper sink than its 10″ counterpart.

Over 730 reviews gave this an average of 4.3 stars out of 5. 69% were 5-star ratings. Only 10% of reviews were 2-stars or less, and most appeared to be issues of personal preference, not product performance.

This LUCID 12 Inch King Hybrid Mattress is at the top of my budget but also at the top of my list for best hybrid king mattress under $500.

 

LUCID 12 Inch King Latex Hybrid Mattress – Memory Foam – Responsive Latex Layer – Premium Steel Coils – Medium Firm Feel – Temperature Neutral

This mattress has a 10″ or 12″ option. I evaluated it at 12″.

6.5-inch, high-quality steel coils are individually-wrapped to increase airflow, isolate motion, and conform to individual sleep styles. The 3.5″ plush memory foam layer is topped with natural latex and infused with gel for the perfect combination of sink and spring.

This mattress claims to be the perfect mattress for those who want the comfort of memory foam with the hypoallergenic and breathable properties of latex.

An attractive, two-tone cover finishes the elegant look of this mattress, and it is backed by a 10-year U.S. warranty against manufacturer defects.

The 12″ mattress is medium-firm with slight sink.

Over 400 reviews gave this an average of 4.3 stars out of 5. 71% were 5-star ratings. Only 10% of reviews were 2-stars or less.

 

Signature Sleep 6147559 Contour Hybrid 12″ Independently Encased Coil Memory Foam, King Bed Mattress Conventional, White

This king mattress is available in a 8″, 10″, or 12″ option.

The Signature Sleep deluxe hybrid mattress combines high-performance independently encased coils, memory foam, and convoluted foam to deliver edge-to-edge support. Made of high-performance independently encased coils, the core is designed to eliminate motion disturbance and keep you sleeping soundly.

The memory foam and convoluted foam in the pillow-top allow for complete relaxation by molding to your body, relieving key pressure points and promoting airflow and breathability.

This mattress is covered with a soft non-removable and non-washable cover made with 60% polyester and 40% rayon. It has a 10-year warranty.

This Signature Sleep hybrid king mattress has a medium firmness.

Over 9000 reviews gave this an average of 4.3 stars out of 5. 71% were 5-star ratings. Only 8% of reviews were 2-stars or less. However, the most recent review on this particular mattress was over two years old.

This Signature Sleep hybrid is on my short list for best hybrid king mattress under $500, but the lack of recent reviews makes me a bit leery.

 

LINENSPA 12 Inch Gel Memory Foam Hybrid Mattress – Ultra Plush – Individually Encased Coils – Sleeps Cooler Than Regular Memory Foam – Edge Support – Quilted Foam Cover – King

This high-profile hybrid combines the edge support of an innerspring mattress with the comfort and adaptability of memory foam. Heavy gauge, 8-inch coils topped with transition foam and a 2-inch layer of gel memory foam make this the softest bed in the LINENSPA line.

Gel-infused memory foam provides extra support and dissipates heat normally locked in by memory foam.

This mattress is backed by a 10-year U.S. warranty against manufacturer defects.

Firmness for this LINENSPA 12 Inch Gel Memory Foam Hybrid Mattress is listed as “plush.”

Over 450 reviews gave this an average of 4.3 stars out of 5. 73% were 5-star ratings. 11% of reviews were 2-stars or less.

This Linenspa gel memory foam hybrid mattress is on my short list for best hybrid king mattress under $500, especially as it’s in the middle of my budget range.